Logo Logo
  • About
  • Accented
    • Playstates
    • Jets Flight Control
  • The Other
    • Review Index
    • Link Bank
    • Ideas/Images Bank

Refining the Defining of Games

February 19, 2017 by Chris Billows in Playstates Theory, Republic of Bloggers tags: Game Philosophy, Games Analysis

I came across Oscar Barda’s Gamasutra article where he make a bold attempt to define games.

The definition of games is a game in itself, havings its own traps and dangers. There are going to people who are going to vehemently disagree, and people that will simply ignore you. I fall into a third category of people that appreciates his effort, but would like to see it refined.

Oscar’s definition of “Games as a formalized fiction of doing” is pretty accurate. There is nothing to fundamentally disagree with, but I think that it doesn’t provide enough depth.

While Oscar’s definition can be accurate, I think it is perhaps too broad, captures too many things that makes the definition not helpful when you dig deeper. After all, in saying that human beings are living creatures is an accurate statement, it is so broad that humans are not distinguishable from other animals or even insects. A definition is most helpful when its both broad and deep enough.

The problem with “Games being a formalized fiction of doing” is that there are too many other human activities that fall into that definition or neglects game activities that don’t fit his definition, such as:

  • Any form of acting including role playing.
  • Practicing a skill or activity for performance. When we practice a performance, we pretend to demonstrate mastery of a skill/activity so when we are ready, we can perform to the best of our ability. Practicing an instrument for a performance is not a game.
  • Sports are a kind of game but when I dig deeper not all games are sports. Oscar does not provide an explanation about how sports are different from games, just saying that they are played for their own sake. This can be said about any hobby.
  • Puzzles are a form of play but when I dig deeper they are not games.
  • Gambling is a kind of game, but does not fit his definition since playing for money tends to be serious and not a fiction.

There are people who will argue that these diverse activities are all simply kinds of games. I disagree with that blanket type of rationalization and believe that a more accurate definition can be elicited.

Oscar may be quite happy with his definition and will use it to guide his understanding. He is welcome, as is anybody to accept any definition they wish. What I am attempting to argue is that a definition can be ‘right’ but not be ‘right enough’. It can be broadly accurate, but does not pass the depth test of meaning.

In future posts I’ll be illustrating what I believe is a definition of games that is both broad and deep enough to be helpful.

About The Author: Chris Billows

Chris Billows is a knowledge seeker who believes in social responsibility, a health care professional, and a business dabbler. The Journals of Doc Surge is his personal blog. Doc Surge (a cool synonym for Billows) is inspired by Doc Brass from the Planetary Comic series who in turn was inspired by the 1930s pulp hero Doc Savage.
Cyberg Applications
Winnipeg Jets Player Transactions 2015-16

Leave a Comment! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts
  • The Borderland
  • Happy New Year for 2025
  • GameDev Skills: Year Three
  • Video Game Development Segments: Nerds
  • Happy New Year for 2024
Recent Comments
  • Traversing from Heropath to Mythway – Heropath on GameDev Skills: Year Three
  • Dev Update: A Fork in the (Hero)path – Heropath on GameDev Skills: Year Two
  • Dev Update: A Fork in the (Hero)path – Heropath on The Axiom of Player Development
  • Chase the Chalice – Heropath on Happy New Year to Thee in 2023
  • Thoughts on Fundamentals (Time / Endings) – Heropath on Why Games Are About Play of Measurement
Categories
  • Business Beller
  • Hobby Heedings
  • Jets Flight Control
  • Mental Mischief
  • Nerdism in Winnipeg
  • Playstates Theory
  • Political Ponderings
  • Republic of Bloggers
  • Spirit Speculations
  • Uncategorized
204-430-9956
© Chris Billows. All Rights Reserved.